What Makes a Strong Retaliation Case?

September 26, 2023
What Makes a Strong Retaliation Case?

Here's what you need to know:

  • Retaliation cases continue to make up the majority of charges filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
  • It’s something that employers need to consider carefully — because landing in a costly settlement or lawsuit can significantly interrupt your cash flow, lower morale, stimulate employee churn, and harm the company's brand reputation
  • Retaliation, discrimination, and hostile work environments are bad for business, and employees shouldn’t be punished for doing what’s right and informing the company of problems on the ground

Workplace retaliation cases continue to make up the majority of charges filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). These are cases alleging retaliation-based discrimination, and they constituted 51.6 percent of all EEOC charges in 2022. For EEOC retaliation cases won, plaintiffs were awarded a total of more than $220 million in monetary benefits. That number does not include compensation acquired through litigation.

Essentially, this means that workplace retaliation charges can have exorbitant consequences, and more so in cases of a retaliation lawsuit.

This is something that employers need to consider carefully. Landing in a costly settlement or lawsuit can significantly interrupt your cash flow, lower morale, stimulate employee churn and harm the company’s brand reputation. And where this type of retaliation in the workplace actually exists, it can create an even more toxic environment.

That said, workplace retaliation cases aren’t necessarily easy to win. And many organizations forced to defend themselves opt to hire an experienced workplace retaliation lawyer. Naturally it’s best to reduce the risk of being charged with or subjected to it by gaining knowledge and taking preventative measures. To get a better idea of what constitutes retaliation, let’s look at a strong case.

What makes a good retaliation case? Three points to consider

A strong retaliation case must show three things:

  1. An employee faced discrimination or harassment in the workplace.
  2. They reported the incident.
  3. The employee was then fired, demoted or otherwise punished for their complaint.

If an employee can show all three actions that occurred with hard evidence, such as reports, witness statements, emails, recordings and similar items, then they may have a strong case.

Let’s take a look at a real case to see how this plays out.

In a recent court case, Harris v. FedEx Corporation, 4:21-cv-01651 (S.D. Texas, May 19, 2021), Jennifer Harris won $366 million in a racial discrimination and retaliation lawsuit against FedEx. Here’s what happened:

Presumably, Jennifer Harris was a top performer when working for FedEx. Not only was she awarded the President’s Club twice, but she had positive evaluations and was promoted six times between 2007 and 2019.

On March 8, 2019, when her manager Michelle Lamb asked her to take a demotion, Harris filed an internal complaint regarding racism. After two months, and outside company policy, she received a letter detailing her “unacceptable performance.”

In addition, her manager, Lamb, allegedly sabotaged Harris’ commission structures, belittled her in front of coworkers and refused to assign her clients within her district.

When Harris, an African American woman, approached HR for racism against her by her White manager, they told her it would “blow over.”

Finally, Jennifer Harris was given a warning and subsequently terminated.

The plaintiff’s claim alleged that FedEx, despite being a worldwide company, failed to hire and train HR staff, managers and other supervisors about racial discrimination.

Why this retaliation lawsuit stands out

Reasons why Harris’ workplace retaliation case stands out include:

  • Her manager, Michelle Lamb, did not follow FedEx protocol by sending a Letter of Counseling. Managers must have a documented discussion regarding performance before this letter is sent.
  • There is a clear paper trail of Harris’ positive performance, even while working under Lamb.
  • Harris was openly belittled in front of her peers, creating witness testimony.
  • They documented her complaint, but Harris received no support from HR.

A strong retaliation case is backed by substantial evidence. Jennifer Harris provided numerous instances of discrimination and successfully linked it to her termination.

What counts as retaliation?

Workplace retaliation doesn’t just occur from reporting discrimination or harassment. A manager or supervisor can be accused of retaliation when punishing an employee for a protected activity.

Protected activities can mean:

  • Reporting company policy violations.
  • Asking for earned overtime pay.
  • Whistleblowing.
  • Participating in an investigation.
  • Talking about or forming a union.
  • Taking leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA).
  • Filing for worker’s compensation.

It’s important to note that in a retaliation case, whether or not someone discriminated against someone is not the key argument. The only thing that matters is finding out if someone fired or punished the employee for reporting an incident in good faith.

For example, even if there is no proof of sexual harassment or discrimination, the jury could still find an organization guilty of retaliation.

What evidence matters in a retaliation lawsuit?

In terms of how to prove retaliation, there are many types of evidence that people can use in a retaliation lawsuit. An employee who is suing an employer for retaliation may have evidence showing discrimination and harassment and will connect that to their termination or demotion.

Common types of evidence for retaliation claims include:

  • Call and chat logs.
  • Company policies.
  • Emails, letters and memos.
  • Employee handbooks.
  • Employee performance reviews and history.
  • Personal notes and journal entries.
  • Text messages.
  • Witness testimony.
  • Videos, voicemails and other recordings.

What are common signs of retaliation in the workplace?

For the HR team, it’s essential to identify potential retaliation signs early. Warning signs that a manager might be retaliating against an employee may include:

  • Demotions.
  • Bad mouthing an employee in public.
  • Reassigning an employee to another department.
  • Reducing an employee’s hours without warning.
  • Not allowing an employee to change shifts.
  • Excluding the employee from meetings.

Some warning signs can be more subtle or inconspicuous, as in:

  • Not allowing an employee to take time off.
  • Unfair performance reviews.
  • Interfering with internal promotions.
  • Blacklisting former employees.
  • Not inviting the employee to work events.
  • Demoting, terminating, or reassigning the employee’s friends.

How can employers prevent retaliation claims?

The Human Resources department is the first firewall against retaliation. Whenever possible, it’s better to prevent retaliation before it starts. And if HR notices a problem, it’s essential to conduct an internal investigation and prevent it from becoming a serious issue.

The good news is that there are action steps your HR team can take to reduce the likelihood of a retaliation incident:

  • Draft a sound anti-retaliation policy.
  • Use examples of what not to do and offer suggestions.
  • Explain what actions are protected from retaliation.
  • Ensure every worker receives retaliation training when onboarded and promoted.
  • Document all retaliation claims well.
  • Set up a third-party, anonymous hotline to receive complaints.
  • Provide guidance to managers and supervisors for handling interpersonal conflict without using retaliation.
  • Have an open-door policy.
  • Map out a clear internal investigation roadmap for retaliation claims.
  • Be discreet and empathetic with employees when they come to HR with claims.

Since retaliation often stems from punishing employees for good faith reporting, it’s also important to offer training and policies for managers and HR regarding:

  • Diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI).
  • Discrimination.
  • Harassment.
  • Unionizing.
  • Civility and respect in the workplace.
  • When an employee is not obligated to listen to their supervisor.

Human Resources is responsible for bringing new people into the organization, so it’s critical that the HR department has regular training to spot discriminatory characteristics and behaviors during hiring, onboarding and throughout an employee’s career.

It’s essential to put a stop to toxic workplaces

Retaliation cases aren’t just an expensive settlement — a manager who retaliates against employees fosters a toxic work environment. As a result, the affected department or even the entire organization can begin to suffer from lower employee morale, broken trust and reduced productivity.

And if word gets out, which it typically does, customers may find alternatives.

The fact of the matter is that retaliation, discrimination and hostile work environments are bad for business. Employees shouldn’t be punished for doing what’s right and informing the company of problems on the ground.

For HR managers, knowing how to deal with sexism, racism and other social issues can open the door to better communication and conflict resolution. It can also help your team make better decisions with new hires and training.

Our guide to racism and social issues in the workplace dives deep into how your team can tackle injustice at work.

rise-nav_banner.jpg

Inspirational stories and on-the-ground perspectives shaping the future of work.

Start here
PF_2023_Insights_Ad.jpg

On-demand sessions

Start here
jebbit-peo-ad-new.webp

Is a PEO right for you? Take our assessment.

Start here
Additional Articles
esac.png
ESAC Accreditation
We comply with all ESAC standards and maintain ESAC accreditation since 1995.
irs.png
Certified PEO
A TriNet subsidiary is classified as a Certified Professional Employer Organization by the IRS.5.